The short version (go read his firsthand account for the longer one) is that after writing and recording (at Gaga's request) the parody, Gaga did not give the go ahead for it to be a single. That's fine. That's her choice. It's a bit dickish of her to ask him to do all that work and then turn it down without any reason as to why, but still, her choice. I'm just wondering what about it Gaga took issue with. He didn't lie or slander her at all. He did what he does best: Parody. Satire. With outstanding musicality. Really, Gaga must have a sense of humor (how else would she wake up in the morning?) so what was her problem with Al's piece?So yeah, I loves me some Weird Al. Anyway, today, I see from his Twitter feed that he has a new single. A parody of Lady Gaga's "Born This Way". Awesome! I've been wanting him to do some "Polka Face" action for a while and this new single is just the--wait, what's this? It's not a single? I read his blog on the Gaga Saga and I'm actually a little saddened.
Anyway, Al did what anyone with free use would do. He posted the finished track on YouTube.
As is often the case, I prefer Al's version of the song. (The other day, "Don'tcha" by the Pussy Cat Dolls came on my shuffle and I thought it sounded horrible without accordion.) I think I've listened to it 8 times today because it's just so much fun. I'm being generous if I say I've listened to "Born This Way" more than thrice.
What makes me sad about this... Al wouldn't have made a dime off of this song. He said that since he didn't want to sully the underlying message "Born This Way" has, he would donate all proceeds made from the sale of the song to the Human Rights Campaign. Now, that piece is up on YouTube and mp3s for free download will soon follow. No money is being made at all for anyone. (He hopes that those who like the song will take the money they would've spent on a download and donate it to the HRC.) On a more selfish note: can you imagine what a live performance of this would've looked like?
I'm sorry that it didn't get to happen. I, along with other fans of both Al and Gaga, hope that sometime they can sit down together, hash this out and make something fun and potent. Hell, when Al and Avril Lavigne collaborated on his parody of "Complicated", that rocked. But until then, I will just wait ever so patiently for his new album. See... this is me, being patient.
Cheers, Al. You're fantastic.